Looking back: History of the SVA Collier Award
by Joanna C. Scherer

3/20/2012

From the beginning of SVA in 1985 not all of us were using film and or video in our research. The still picture (both historical and contemporary) was to some of us the unit of study for research and communication of anthropological knowledge. Obviously some scholars were more creative and/or articulate with their methodology and research than others so it was not much of a leap of faith to consider honoring such original contributors with an award.

The idea for an SVA award that promoted the use of still pictures for research and communication of anthropological knowledge was thus present in SVA circles from the beginning of the organization. The first records I can find of the articulation of such an award was at the SVA Board meeting in Chicago in 1987. During the discussion of the Film and Video Festival headed by Joan Swayze Williams, Film & Video Festival Organizer, there was general discussion, of formalizing special awards:

“Several possibilities were mentioned: 1) best ethnographic (popular) film accompanied by an article or book; 2) book or monograph that uses visuals to the best effect; 3) a category that would emphasize products in which the visuals were produced by the people under study, rather than by the anthropologist; 4) outstanding contribution to visual anthropology – the actual definition covering any or all of the above categories; and 5) anthropology in media prize to go to a first production of great promise, rather than to already established professionals.”

Item number 2 of the above list was to this author the beginning of the yet to be named Collier Award. Karl Heider, Richard Chalfen and Joan Williams were charged with forming an ad-hoc committee for the SVA Awards that they hoped would be presented at the full AAA gathering on Saturday night of the meeting where other awards were presented.

At the SVA board meeting in Washington, D.C. in November 1989 the subjects of awards was discussed again. The board was told that the AAA had made the determination that “all non-AAA awards will be presented by their own individual units, only 6 general AAA awards will be presented at the Saturday evening ceremony.” It was thus decided to have the SVA award winners given at a Wednesday night SVA special presentation and that the award winners would be listed in future AAA programs (check when awards were first listed for SVA in the program). The discussion at the 1989 meeting about kinds of SVA awards broadened. Museum exhibitions, film plus printed book/journal/article best integrated combination, thesis award and others were added to the discussion. It was too much for the brief time period of our board meeting (that were then just an hour long) and our President at that time, Karl Heider didn’t “sense much support for any of the ideas, therefore best to table them….Will Ira [Abrams] write up a proposal for a general award encompassing all the above? Heider hands problem over to Dick [Chalfen] to work on.” The following February Karl Heider gathered together the ideas/proposals for the awards.

At the SVA board meeting in San Francisco in 1992 under the film/video festival report Joan Williams established a three-tier award system for the festival. A proposal concerning “an award for a book in visual anthropology was also directed to the executive committee for further consideration.” The record for the yet to be established award for a work (book, exhibit, web site or multimedia production) recognizing an exemplary use of still photographs in anthropology seems to have lain below the radar until the SVA Board Meeting in San Francisco in 2000. As a result of that board meeting in April 2001 Harald Prins, president, circulated an e-mail officially proposing the Collier Award as a method of promoting and recognizing excellent uses of still photography in anthropology.

Dear SVA Board Members, As indicated a few weeks ago, I would send you the details re. the John Collier Award. During the 2000 SVA Annual Board meeting in San Francisco, it was moved to institutionalize this award as a means of promotion and recognition of exemplary use of still photography in anthropology. As such, the award is for a finished product of the same order as a film or book. It is possible that the Maxwell Museum, which houses the Collier research collection, may be cosponsoring the award. In order to avoid confusion, the following summary is pertinent:

Name: John Collier Jr. Award

Category: Outstanding Book, Exhibit, Web site, or Multimedia Production demonstrating substantial use of still photographs as communication and/or as the primary source of data gathering, analysis, and research on which the anthropological product is based.

Objective: Recognition of excellence and promotion of awareness of still photography as visual record in communication and research.

Occasion: Irregular, but no more than one prize each year

Nominations Process: Open, submissions to SVA Executive Board before 1 April.

Jury: SVA President and two other SVA members with special expertise and/or interest in still photography

Prize: Still Photograph from the Collier Collection and Certificate

Time and Place: The prize shall be presented conform to the SVA rituals during the annual meetings of the AAA.

In the hope that this meets your approval, Sincerely Yours, Harald Prins, SVA President

Thus the Collier Award was created. At the 2005 SVA Board meeting in Washington, D.C. Peter Biella, president, asked for comments about the Collier Award. John Bishop recommended that the nominations should come from the Board not from the film jury and that was the moment when the Collier Award was weaned from the Film and Video organizer.[iv]

The project must be nominated by a current member of the American Anthropology Association. A complete submission packet consists of:

• A letter of nomination from the AAA member covering why the work deserves the award, as well as the name, book title or exhibit, website or multimedia production, publisher, author’s mailing address, phone and email.

• A letter of consent from the work’s author.

• Four copies of the work (if a physical copy exists). These copies should be requested by the author from the publisher to be sent directly to the committee.

Completed submission materials must be received by the deadline .

Submissions cannot be nominated directly from the publisher but the copies of the work may be sent directly from the publisher to the committee. Collections of writings by multiple authors will not be considered nor can previous winners submit another time.

The same work may be submitted a maximum of two times. The SVA Collier Award board appointed committee then reviews the submitted works to decide on its merits. Winners are announced during the SVA/AAA Business Meeting and presented with a John Collier Jr. or Mary Collier print, courtesy of the Collier Family Collection, a certificate of recognition and award recognition stickers to place on the work.

• Deadlines for 2023 Submission and Award Notification:

• May 31: Deadline for receipt of nomination materials and submission to SVA.

• August 31: Committee decision will be submitted to SVA President and Secretary.

• Sept 10: Award information submitted to AAA program committee.

Submissions for 2023 should be mailed to:

The Collier Committee c/o Elizabeth Cartwright, 921 S. 8th Avenue, Stop 8005, Pocatello, ID 83209-8005

Questions may be directed to: lizcartwright@isu.edu